
Los Doyers were active again at the trading deadline this year, acquiring Ted Lilly, Ryan Theriot and a grip of cash for Blake DeWitt and two seemingly average minor league pitchers.
While there are plenty of people in the Dodger community that are pleased with this deal, I'm not so sure it's really much of anything.
Lilly has to be considered an improvement over Monasterios, Ely, McDonald or whomever else you were going to throw out there in the 5th slot. But he is not a dealbreaker. And while I'm not sold that Oswalt was even of that calliber either, there's an argument that the Dodgers don't really need a starting pitcher.
Our offense right now is abysmal, everyone knows that. Theriot is hardly a spark, especially considering DeHitt (is this the last time I get to write that?) has been above average at getting on base. And though Theriot is not why this deal was done, it stands as a point of concern.
Theriot is going to be much more expensive that DeWitt going forward and surely he is not locked up until 2014 under team control - in fact, he's only locked up for 2010, with two arbitration years ahead.
With the way Monasterios has been decent and Ely has been at times great, at times serviceable, rarely bad, adding Lilly to supplant them seems like a move only someone believing in grisled, old veterans would make.
If the Dodgers felt they needed a new starting pitcher, I felt like they should have gone after a guy that can at least pitch for you next year, like Paul Maholm (who also has a team option for 2012, though I heard the world is ending then). Lilly is much better than Maholm, but hear me out. As of right now the only Dodger starting pitchers currently in the rotation under team control for next year are Kershaw and Billingsley. That is scary.
Padilla could return on another one year deal and Kuroda could possibly also come back (though some rumors are that he would like to return to Japan), so maybe they'd be fine, but you can't count on that. Now you cannot count on Lilly, either. Though he'd be a type A free agent, he comes with a high price tag if you offer him arbitration, and we all know the Dodgers' feelings about spending money these days.
So this deal is not that exciting and does not address the Dodgers biggest concern area. Oh well, I hope Lilly reverts to being a glimpse of his old self instead of the roller coaster he's been this year or that he can fall in line with the rest of our starting pitching of late, which has been amazing. But I won't hold my breathe.
Who knows, with how many hustling white guys there are on the team (Blake, Carroll, Ethier, Johnson, half of Martin, Podsednik, and now Theriot) maybe they'll all grow beards, talk about Cowboy-ing up and win us a World Series.


